|
|
< First part
Results
The results of stifness test are illustrated in Table 2. Despite greater
diameters due to the increased tapers,the bending moment of both instruments
in all sizes satisfied ANSI/ADA requirements. Mean values were much less
than the maximum values set forth in the specification. Bending moments
were significantly greater for ProFile .06 than for ProFile .04 in all
sizes. Values increased regularly with increased instruments size for
both tapers.
Table 2: means and standard deviations for bending moment (gm-cm)
at 45 degrees.
| ProFile .04 |
Mean |
SD |
ProFile .06 |
Mean |
SD |
| Size 15 |
14.35 |
1.36 |
Size 15 |
27.60 |
2.84 |
| Size 20 |
22.71 |
2.84 |
Size 20 |
40.76 |
4.69 |
| Size 25 |
32.52 |
2.80 |
Size 25 |
58.20 |
5.55 |
| Size 30 |
49.37 |
4.12 |
Size 30 |
83.94 |
8.34 |
| Size 35 |
73.25 |
6.48 |
Size 35 |
143.73 |
12.05 |
| Size 40 |
94.00 |
7.64 |
Size 40 |
115.88 |
14.43 |
Discussion
Mechanical properties of NiTi endodontic instruments have been reported
in some previous studies), but none of them completely evaluated Maillefer
ProFile rotary instruments. Only Walcott and Himel (10) investigated the
torsional properties of NiTi,rotary, .04 tapered "U" files in sizes 15,25
and 35. They showed that instruments satisfied and far exceeded the standard
for maximum torque and for angular deflection at maximum point. Higher
flexibility of NiTi instrumets was also demonstrated by Tepel et al.(11),
who reported that NiTi K-files displayed lower resistance to bending and
torque values than conventional SS K-files.
These favourable properties are extremely useful in clinical practice.
Nickel-titanium instruments have a great ability to recover from gentle
distortions. They possess remarkable flexibility that can withstand the
rapid,repeated distortions of rotation in curved canals. Moreover, a more
flexible instrument can more easily follow the root canal if there is
a curvature. A rigid file tends to create aberrations in curved canals
including zips and canal transportation., which are a result of the inherent
stifness of the metal.It is important to note that also the .06 tapered
instruments shows excellent bending properties, which permit safe clinical
use.
It has been shown that the NiTi alloy has excellent springback and superelastic
properties (12). The super-elastic property can be described briefly.
The stress value remains fairly constant up to a certain point of instrument
deformation. At the same time,when the deformation rebounds, the stress
value remains fairly constant. In clinical endodontics this typical behaviour
reduces the tendency of straightening the curved root canals, and the
risk of canal transportation. In addition these properties allowed the
idea of a safe rotary file to be born. The stainless steel files did not
have the flexibility to be used for rotary movements in curved canals,
without significantly altering the canal configuration and perforating
the canal walls.
The mean values of the tested files in the present study support this
affirmation. With the advent of nickel-titanium it became practical to
develop a file type of instrument that could be effectively and safely
used as a rotary root canal instruments in curved canals.The results of
the present study indicated that all measurements satisfied the ANSI/ADA
Specification no.28 standard values for bending tests. Both ProFile .04
and .06 instruments showed consistency of mechanical properties among
different sizes. Moreover, values increased regularly with increased instrument
sizes..An improved quality of manufacturing process ( it is technically
more difficult and complicated to fabricate NiTi than SS instruments)
can be a possible reason for these constant results. On the contrary,
inconsistencies in taper,flute number and design,and shape of the pilot
tip could increase stiffness.
ProFile .04 instruments resulted most flexible,and therefore best suited
for instrumentation of severely curved and narrow canals. The more flexible
instruments tend to negotiate curved canals better and reduce the tendency
of straightening, zipping, ledging or perforation of curved canals. The
excellent flexibility of .06 ProFile instruments allows safe instrumentation
of moderately curved root canals.
The result of the present study demonstrated that ProFile nickel-titanium,
variable taper, instruments have excellent bending properties which let
it possible to operate these instruments with a low-speed rotary handpiece,
that potentially allows shaping of narrow curved root canals without aberrations.
Bibliografy
- Council on Dental Materials,Instruments and Equipment. Revised American
National Standards Institute/American Dental Association Specification
No.28 for root canal files and reamers,type K (revised 1988).
- International Standard Organization:ISO 3630-1.Dental root canal instruments.Part
1: files, reamers, barbed broaches, rasps, paste carriers,explorers
and cotton broaches. Genf: International Standard Organization 1992
G.Gambarini Flexibility of Profile Nickel-Titanium Rotary Instruments
51
- Craig RG,McIlwain ED,Peyton FA.Bending and torsion properties of endodontic
instruments. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral pathol 1968; 25: 239-54
- Krupp JD,Brantley WA, Gerstein H.An investigation of the torsional
and bending properties of seven brands of endodontic files. J Endodon
1984;10: 372-80
- Walia H,Brantley WA,Gerstein H. An initial investigation of the bending
and torsional properties of Nitinol root canal files. J Endodon 1988:14;
346-51
- Mc Spadden JT. Rationale for rotary nickel-titanium instruments: light
speed pre series McXIM's. Product information and instruction for the
use of Ni-Ti endodontic instruments. Chattanooga,TN: NT Co.
- Horn A.Instructional video. Profile 0.04 taper series 29 rotary instruments.
Tulsa Dental Products. 1994
- Serene TP,Adams JD,SaxenaA. Nickel-titanium instruments: applications
in endodontics. Ishiyaku EuroAmerica, St.Louis 1995
- Short JA,Morgan LA,Baumgartner CJ.A comparison of canal centering
ability of four instrumentation techniques.J Endodon 1997;23: 503-7
- Walcott J,Himel VT. Torsional properties of nickel-titanium versus
stainless steel endodontic files. J Endodon 1997:23:217-20
- Tepel J,Schafer E,Hoppe W.properties of endodontic hand instruments
used in a rotary motion.Part 3.Resistance to bending and fracture. J
Endodon 1997;23: 141-5
- Miyazaki S,Otsuka K,Suzuki Y. Transformation pseudoelasticity and
deformation behaviour in a ti-50.6 at % Ni alloy. Acta Met 1976; 24:
207-26.
|
|
Would you like
to co-operate with us?
The invitation is for all the collegues who
wish to develop a specific subject or present clinical case-reports
of particular interest in the field of Restorative Dentistry,
Endodontics and Periodontics.
Texts and photographic- radiographics material
must comply with the Instructions
to Authors.
Further request for information and explanation,
or suggestions of scientific articles/papers about subjects
different from the above mentioned ones, may be sent direct
to dental-smile@bec.it
|
|
|